Payroll Services Team Lead - Remote

Overview

This role involves joining Payroll Tax Operations (PTO) as a Lead Tax Processor and Subject Matter Expert (Level X5). You will provide technical leadership for the team by independently resolving the most complex, high-stakes, and ambiguous customer or internal escalations. You will also own approval governance for standard operating procedures, deliver structured coaching, and support routines that build workforce capacity.

SelectTime / Role Details

SelectTime employees provide virtual expert services to customers, year-round, with flexible hours and schedules.

• Minimum: 20 hours per week
• Maximum: up to 40 hours per week based on business need
• Hourly, non-exempt position; eligible for overtime pay

Responsibilities

• Serve as the primary real-time go-to technical expert for TP1, TP2, and TP3 staff by answering complex questions and teaching resolution paths to build team capability.
• Author, technically review, and formally approve Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) and Knowledge Base (KB) articles across core operations.
• Conduct structured, formal coaching sessions at least once per quarter using the SBIC feedback model to close skill gaps.
• Lead or contribute to team huddles, group QA sessions, and performance board updates; act as primary backup facilitator for Daily Stand-Ups when the M1 manager is unavailable.
• Maintain end-to-end mastery of daily business operations, including independent oversight of team WIP management, backlog reduction, and aging reports; recommend staffing adjustments to the M1 manager.
• Resolve the most severe State and Federal payroll tax notices in the queue, including multi-quarter IRS discrepancies, state audit inquiries, and cross-jurisdictional penalty assessments.
• Approve highly complex amended Federal (Form 941-X, W-2c) and State returns across all states, ensuring complete audit trails and ledger reconciliation.
• Identify systemic trends, emerging compliance risks, and Known Issues (KIs); communicate findings to the M1 manager and cross-functional stakeholders with data-driven recommended responses.
• Represent the team in cross-functional meetings, maintain a strong compliance focus, and provide risk-informed alternatives under pressure.

Required Qualifications

• 4+ years of payroll tax experience with a demonstrated focus on complex tax defect resolution, notice response, and multi-state amendment filings.
• Prior experience functioning formally as a lead, senior specialist, or SME, with specific examples of coaching, mentoring, or training junior staff through nuanced resolution scenarios.
• Expert knowledge of tax payment and filing regulations across all US jurisdictions, including extensive experience with local municipal tax systems (e.g., PA, OH) and state-level programs (e.g., PFML, SDI).
• Advanced writing skills used to create, review, and approve Standard Operating Procedures and technical documents for a tax processor audience without requiring revision.
• Demonstrated extreme ownership of team Service Level Agreements by consistently identifying “red flags” and resolving workflow barriers before they impact the business.
• A consistent “validation-first” mindset—bringing fully vetted potential solutions and technical alternatives to leadership rather than only identifying problems.
• 5+ years of experience independently handling highly sensitive customer and internal peer escalations with minimal leadership guidance.
• 4+ years of experience in contact center, customer service, or back-office operations enabling seamless navigation of high-volume, service-related business needs.
• Comfortable leveraging and testing AI (artificial intelligence) tools to complete daily tasks and support continuous improvement across team workflows.

Preferred Qualifications

• Certified Payroll Professional (CPP) designation is highly preferred, or expected within 18 months of placement (Enrolled Agent designation is a strong differentiator).
• High proficiency in driving Lean management practices, including consistent execution of Daily Huddles, Gemba Walks, and use of Daily Management boards to resolve operational bottlenecks.
• History of exceeding standard metrics while maintaining a personal quality accuracy rate of 95% or higher.

Compensation & Benefits

This role includes an eligible cash bonus, equity rewards, and benefits in accordance with applicable plans and programs.

Expected base pay range:

• California (Bay Area): $46.00 - $62.00
• Southern California: $46.00 - $62.00
• Colorado: $38.00 - $51.00
• District of Columbia: $38.00 - $51.00
• Hawaii: $39.50 - $53.50
• Illinois: $38.00 - $51.00
• Maine: $34.50 - $46.50
• Maryland: $38.00 - $51.00
• Massachusetts: $39.50 - $53.50
• Minnesota: $34.50 - $46.50
• New Jersey: $39.50 - $53.50
• New York: $46.00 - $62.00
• Ohio: $34.50 - $46.50
• Vermont: $38.00 - $51.00
• Virginia: $38.00 - $51.00
• Washington: $39.50 - $53.50

Pay offered is based on job-related knowledge, skills, experience, and work location. Regular comparisons across categories of ethnicity and gender are conducted to support fair pay.